Project:Lockers: Difference between revisions

From CoMakingSpace Wiki

(linked first finished SketchUp design)
m (InfoBox title (why was this last in an alphabetic list, anyway?!))
 
(4 intermediate revisions by the same user not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
{{ProjectInfoBox
{{ProjectInfoBox
|project title=building lockers for our members
|project title=Plywood Lockers for our Members
|image=Sketching lockers.PNG
|image=Sketching lockers.PNG
|status=in progress
|status=paused until we run out again
|date=Oct 2017
|date=Oct 2017
|initiator={{£}}, [[Ciaran]], [[Patrick]], [[Mitja]]
|initiator={{£}}, [[Ciaran]], [[Patrick]], [[Mitja]]
|team=Ed, [[User:Moritz|Moritz]]
|team=[[User:Ed Green|Ed]], [[User:Moritz|Moritz]], ''Michael''
|materials=[[plywood]] ("Elliotis pine"), [[Wood Screws|wood screws]],<br>[[Piano Hinges|piano hinges]], [[brackets]]
|materials=[[plywood]] ("Elliotis pine"), [[Wood Screws|wood screws]],<br>[[Piano Hinges|piano hinges]], [[brackets]]
|tools=[[Circular Saw|circular saw]], [[Table Saw|table saw]], [[Smoothing Plane|smoothing plane]],<br>[[sandpaper]], [[Cordless Drill|cordless drill]], [[Surform Plane|surform plane]],<br>[[rasps]], [[Japanese Saw|Japanese saw]]
|tools=[[Handheld Circular Saw|handheld circular saw]], [[Table Saw|table saw]], [[Smoothing Plane|smoothing plane]],<br>[[sandpaper]], [[Cordless Drill|cordless drill]], [[Surform Plane|surform plane]],<br>[[rasps]], [[Japanese Saw|Japanese saw]], [[router]]
|software=[[SketchUp]]
|software=[[SketchUp]]
|cost=
|cost=
}}
}}
We are building a bunch of lockers for our [[Common Room|common room]]!
We are building a bunch of lockers for our [[Common Room|common room]]! Design files created with [[SketchUp|SketchUp "Make"]] can be found [https://github.com/LukasFreeze/lockers here] and are released under the Creative Commons "Attribution - Share Alike - Non-Commercial" license.


== Vertical Approach ==
== V1 ==
[[File:Vertical approach.PNG|thumb|200 px|left|three lockers across, two up for a total of six per unit]]
[[File:Vertical approach.PNG|thumb|200 px|left|three lockers across, two up for a total of six per unit]]
The first prototype ("v1", design found [https://github.com/LukasFreeze/lockers/blob/master/lockers%20v1.skp here]) consists of six lockers arranged in a 3{{x}}2 pattern, all in one frame.
The first prototype ("v1") consists of six lockers arranged in a 3{{x}}2 pattern, all in one frame. The doors are held in place with [[Piano Hinges|piano hinges]].


pro:
This way, we needed rather few individual boards (although pretty large) and got pretty close to the minimum amount of wood needed for lockers this size.
* few individual boards
* pretty close to the minimum amount of wood needed for lockers this size


con:
shortcomings:
* large boards to handle
* large contraption, difficult to transport later on
* cleats holding the floors waste a bit of space
* cleats holding the floors waste a bit of space
* floors need to be secured from top and bottom to avoid tampering
* floors need to be secured from top and bottom to avoid tampering
* warping during the build, hard to get right angles


=== Notes on Construction ===
=== Notes on Construction ===
Line 32: Line 29:
<br clear=left>
<br clear=left>


== Horizontal Approach ==
== V2 ==
[[File:Horizontal approach.PNG|thumb|200 px|left|two horizontal boxes make up each six locker unit in this scenario]]
[[User:Moritz|Moritz]] gave some advice for the second unit so the wood would warp less and screws would be used in alternating directions, increasing strength.
[[Ciaran]] proposed an alternative design during the making of the first "vertical" prototype which will be the second one we try.
 
We also made [[Corner Clamping Jigs|corner clamping jigs]] for this build which really helped with getting all the angles right ''(ba-dumm tsss...)''
 
improvements:
* boards should pull themselves more straight
* same material consumption as v1, just a smarter arrangement
* more rigid and accurate framework
* fewer cleats needed to hold the floors
 
shortcomings:
* cleats holding the floors waste a bit of space (less than v1, though)
* ''some'' floors need to be secured from top and bottom to avoid tampering(?)
* floors are not easily removed in case someone wants a double-height locker
 
<br clear=left>
 
== V3 ==
The third unit was completely designed by Moritz and is raised a bit above the ground to eliminate the danger of a swollen bottom board (due to water from cleaning, for example) that would block the doors.
 
Another improvement was supposed to be the use of [[Pot Hinges|pot hinges]] rather than piano hinges, but we realized too late that those would have required larger doors. As the doors had already been cut and prepared, we used piano hinges again.
 
The door edges were nicely rounded over with a [[router]] this time, instead of the simple plane chamfer we made on v1 and v2.


pro:
pro:
* smaller individual boards
* raised off the ground, smaller area of contact
* smaller units - easier to move to a new location one day
* no space lost with cleats


con:
shortcomings:
* more pieces to assemble
* cleats holding the floors waste a bit of space (less than v1, though)
* "double floor" requires more wood and wastes more space than cleats would
* ''some'' floors need to be secured from top and bottom to avoid tampering(?)
* floors are not easily removed in case someone wants a double-height locker
* still no fancy pot hinges


<br clear=left>


== Latch Hardware ==
== Latch Hardware ==
Locking is possible by connecting the holes of a [[bracket]] and a matching piece of flat steel, e.g. with a padlock. Members can of course get creative and operate their locker with any number of [https://makezine.com/projects/keep-cabinets-secure-touch-sensitive-lock/ over-engineered fancy setups] ;-)
Locking is possible by connecting the holes of a [[bracket]] and a matching piece of flat steel, e.g. with a padlock. Members can of course get creative and operate their locker with any number of [https://makezine.com/projects/keep-cabinets-secure-touch-sensitive-lock/ over-engineered fancy setups] ;-)
== Hinges ==
We originally avoided [[Pot Hinges|pot hinges]] due to their cost but it turns out we just didn't look hard enough!
These may be an option for a future version: [https://www.hornbach.de/shop/SlideOn-Topfscharnier-zum-Aufschrauben-vorliegend/7781517/artikel.html (Hornbach)] - we have them at the Space.





Latest revision as of 21:16, 22 September 2022

ProjectInfoBox

Plywood Lockers for our Members

Sketching lockers.PNG
Status: paused until we run out again
Release Date: Oct 2017
Initiator: Lukas, Ciaran, Patrick, Mitja
Team: Ed, Moritz, Michael
Materials Used: plywood ("Elliotis pine"), wood screws,
piano hinges, brackets
Tools Used: handheld circular saw, table saw, smoothing plane,
sandpaper, cordless drill, surform plane,
rasps, Japanese saw, router
Software Used: SketchUp


We are building a bunch of lockers for our common room! Design files created with SketchUp "Make" can be found here and are released under the Creative Commons "Attribution - Share Alike - Non-Commercial" license.

V1

three lockers across, two up for a total of six per unit

The first prototype ("v1") consists of six lockers arranged in a 3 × 2 pattern, all in one frame. The doors are held in place with piano hinges.

This way, we needed rather few individual boards (although pretty large) and got pretty close to the minimum amount of wood needed for lockers this size.

shortcomings:

  • cleats holding the floors waste a bit of space
  • floors need to be secured from top and bottom to avoid tampering
  • warping during the build, hard to get right angles

Notes on Construction

The doors should be hung once everything else is in place as the long boards used tend to shift throughout the build. It also turned out that calculated sizes do not always work out as the thickness of the plywood sheets varies by up to 2 mm.


V2

Moritz gave some advice for the second unit so the wood would warp less and screws would be used in alternating directions, increasing strength.

We also made corner clamping jigs for this build which really helped with getting all the angles right (ba-dumm tsss...)

improvements:

  • boards should pull themselves more straight
  • same material consumption as v1, just a smarter arrangement
  • more rigid and accurate framework
  • fewer cleats needed to hold the floors

shortcomings:

  • cleats holding the floors waste a bit of space (less than v1, though)
  • some floors need to be secured from top and bottom to avoid tampering(?)
  • floors are not easily removed in case someone wants a double-height locker


V3

The third unit was completely designed by Moritz and is raised a bit above the ground to eliminate the danger of a swollen bottom board (due to water from cleaning, for example) that would block the doors.

Another improvement was supposed to be the use of pot hinges rather than piano hinges, but we realized too late that those would have required larger doors. As the doors had already been cut and prepared, we used piano hinges again.

The door edges were nicely rounded over with a router this time, instead of the simple plane chamfer we made on v1 and v2.

pro:

  • raised off the ground, smaller area of contact

shortcomings:

  • cleats holding the floors waste a bit of space (less than v1, though)
  • some floors need to be secured from top and bottom to avoid tampering(?)
  • floors are not easily removed in case someone wants a double-height locker
  • still no fancy pot hinges


Latch Hardware

Locking is possible by connecting the holes of a bracket and a matching piece of flat steel, e.g. with a padlock. Members can of course get creative and operate their locker with any number of over-engineered fancy setups ;-)

Hinges

We originally avoided pot hinges due to their cost but it turns out we just didn't look hard enough!

These may be an option for a future version: (Hornbach) - we have them at the Space.