Project:Foam Inserts: Difference between revisions

From CoMakingSpace Wiki

Keno (talk | contribs)
Updated summaries for foam characteristics
 
(2 intermediate revisions by the same user not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
{{ProjectInfoBox
{{ProjectInfoBox
|project title=
|project title=Shadow Boards
|image=
|image=
|status=
|status=Research
|date=
|date=
|initiator=entropy
|initiator=Keno
|team=[[Lmnl99]], [[Keno]], [[AlexBaumgart]], [[Jeddi]]
|team=[[Lmnl99]], [[Keno]], [[AlexBaumgart]], [[Jeddi]]
|materials=[[EVA Foam|EVA foam]]
|materials=[[PE Foam|PE foam]]
|tools=[[Laser Cutter|laser cutter]]
|tools=[[Laser Cutter|laser cutter]]
|software=
|software=
Line 12: Line 12:
}}
}}


<<<WHAT/WHY?>>>
'''Foam inserts, often called Shadow boards''' are organizational boards used to store and display tools or equipment in clearly designated locations. They are commonly used in manufacturing, workshops, laboratories, and maintenance environments to improve organization, enhance safety, and support lean 5S workplace practices. Each tool has a fixed position marked by a silhouette or “shadow,” allowing users to quickly see if something is missing. They are typically made from '''closed-cell foam sheets''' that are precisely cut with a laser to create snug cavities for each tool. The two most commonly used materials for this purpose are '''EVA (ethylene-vinyl acetate) foam''' and '''PE (polyethylene) foam'''.


== Design ==
Each of these materials has distinct mechanical and visual properties that make them suitable for different design priorities in shadow board construction, such as tool protection, aesthetics, weight, and durability.
<<<HOW?>>>
----


== Cutting ==
== EVA Foam ==
<<<HOW?>>>
'''EVA foam''' is a soft yet durable closed-cell foam known for its '''rubbery flexibility''' and '''smooth appearance'''. The vinyl acetate content gives EVA a characteristic softness and elasticity that many other foams lack.
 
This material is widely used not only in yoga mats, cosplay costumes, and packaging, but also in '''precision-cut foam inlays''' where '''visual appearance and impact protection''' are important.
 
=== Key Properties of EVA Foam in Shadow Boards ===
 
* '''Soft and flexible''' – The smooth, rubbery texture offers '''excellent cushioning for delicate tools''' and protects surfaces from scratches.
* '''Highly durable''' – Resistant to tearing and compression, EVA '''retains its shape after repeated tool insertion and removal'''.
* '''Excellent shock absorption''' – Its elastic structure '''absorbs impacts from dropped tools''', helping to protect expensive instruments.
* '''UV and weather resistant''' – EVA tolerates outdoor or workshop environments without degrading, making it '''suitable for mobile tool boards'''.
* '''Smooth, glossy surface''' – Provides a '''clean, professional finish''' that enhances the visibility of tools against the background.
 
----
 
== PE Foam ==
'''PE foam''' is another closed-cell foam, generally '''stiffer and firmer''' than EVA. It is valued for its '''high strength-to-weight ratio'''.
 
=== Key Properties of PE Foam in Shadow Boards ===
 
* '''Firm and rigid''' – Provides '''structural support''' to the board and '''prevents sagging''' over large tool areas.
* '''Lightweight''' – Despite its strength, it adds '''very little weight''' to wall-mounted or portable shadow boards.
* '''Excellent chemical resistance''' – Resistant to oils, solvents, and other shop chemicals, making it '''durable in industrial environments'''.
* '''Superior thermal insulation''' – Helps '''protect temperature-sensitive tools''' stored in unheated spaces.
* '''Cost-effective''' – Often a '''more economical choice for large boards''' or high-volume tool storage systems.
 
----
 
== EVA vs. PE Foam: Comparison for Laser-Cut Shadow Boards ==
Please note that the table below has been compiled based on claims by different manufacturers and may be optimistic about properties.
{| class="wikitable"
!Property
!EVA Foam
!PE Foam
!Better Option for Shadow Boards
|-
|'''Durability & resilience'''
|Excellent – tear-resistant, high shape recovery
|Good – strong but may crack under heavy stress
|'''EVA''' for long-term, repeated use, but may not make a difference in shadow boards
|-
|'''Softness & cushioning'''
|Excellent – soft, rubbery texture, protects delicate finishes
|Moderate to good – firmer and stiffer
|'''PE''' will hold tools in place better
|-
|'''Shock absorption'''
|Excellent – absorbs impact energy
|Very good – protects and braces stored items
|'''No significant difference for shadow boards'''
|-
|'''Cost'''
|Moderate
|Lower – generally more affordable
|'''PE''' for budget-conscious projects
|-
|'''Weight'''
|Lightweight
|Extremely lightweight
|'''PE''' for large wall-mounted boards
|-
|'''Thermal insulation'''
|Good
|Excellent
|Not relevant
|-
|'''Appearance & finish'''
|Smooth, glossy, often vibrant color
|More textured, matte surface
|'''EVA''' for clean, high-visibility tool layouts
|}
Overall, it seems that PE is the prevalent material for Shadow boards. However, statement is not quantified. To achieve the '''shadow effect''', many users stack '''two contrasting layers of foam''' (for example, black on top of yellow). When the top layer is cut out to match tool shapes, the bright bottom layer becomes visible, highlighting the tool outlines.
----
 
== Design and Layout ==
Before cutting, a layout of the tools must be created. Digital layout tools help arrange silhouettes for efficient use of space. For example, '''ToolKaiser''' is a software tool that allows users to photograph their tools, trace outlines, and export the resulting vector files for laser cutting.
----
 
== Laser Cutting Workflow ==
A general workflow for producing shadow boards with a laser cutter is:
 
# '''Tool Arrangement & Scanning'''  Place the tools on a flat surface, photograph or scan them from above, and import the image into design software.
# '''Vectorization & Layout'''  Trace the outlines into vector paths (e.g., DXF or SVG format) using software like ToolKaiser or a vector graphics editor. Arrange the outlines on the virtual sheet matching the size of the foam.
# '''Laser Preparation'''  Choose PE foam sheets in two contrasting colors. Place the top layer in the laser cutter. Set cutting parameters appropriate for the foam (low power, high speed, multiple passes if needed).
# '''Cutting & Assembly'''  Cut out the tool silhouettes from the top foam layer. Adhere this cut layer onto the contrasting bottom layer using spray adhesive or double-sided tape.
# '''Finishing'''  Mount the finished foam shadow board into a drawer, tool chest, or onto a wall panel.
 
== Notes ==
 
* This article is based on '''preliminary research''' and should be treated as a general overview rather than a complete manufacturing guide.
* Please make sure the foam is safe to cut. It is usually a good idea to source PE foam from Europe in order to avoid being in the dark about potential additives.


== Results ==
== Results ==

Latest revision as of 09:50, 17 September 2025

ProjectInfoBox

Shadow Boards

Status: Research
Initiator: Keno
Team: Lmnl99, Keno, AlexBaumgart, Jeddi
Materials Used: PE foam
Tools Used: laser cutter


Foam inserts, often called Shadow boards are organizational boards used to store and display tools or equipment in clearly designated locations. They are commonly used in manufacturing, workshops, laboratories, and maintenance environments to improve organization, enhance safety, and support lean 5S workplace practices. Each tool has a fixed position marked by a silhouette or “shadow,” allowing users to quickly see if something is missing. They are typically made from closed-cell foam sheets that are precisely cut with a laser to create snug cavities for each tool. The two most commonly used materials for this purpose are EVA (ethylene-vinyl acetate) foam and PE (polyethylene) foam.

Each of these materials has distinct mechanical and visual properties that make them suitable for different design priorities in shadow board construction, such as tool protection, aesthetics, weight, and durability.


EVA Foam

EVA foam is a soft yet durable closed-cell foam known for its rubbery flexibility and smooth appearance. The vinyl acetate content gives EVA a characteristic softness and elasticity that many other foams lack.

This material is widely used not only in yoga mats, cosplay costumes, and packaging, but also in precision-cut foam inlays where visual appearance and impact protection are important.

Key Properties of EVA Foam in Shadow Boards

  • Soft and flexible – The smooth, rubbery texture offers excellent cushioning for delicate tools and protects surfaces from scratches.
  • Highly durable – Resistant to tearing and compression, EVA retains its shape after repeated tool insertion and removal.
  • Excellent shock absorption – Its elastic structure absorbs impacts from dropped tools, helping to protect expensive instruments.
  • UV and weather resistant – EVA tolerates outdoor or workshop environments without degrading, making it suitable for mobile tool boards.
  • Smooth, glossy surface – Provides a clean, professional finish that enhances the visibility of tools against the background.

PE Foam

PE foam is another closed-cell foam, generally stiffer and firmer than EVA. It is valued for its high strength-to-weight ratio.

Key Properties of PE Foam in Shadow Boards

  • Firm and rigid – Provides structural support to the board and prevents sagging over large tool areas.
  • Lightweight – Despite its strength, it adds very little weight to wall-mounted or portable shadow boards.
  • Excellent chemical resistance – Resistant to oils, solvents, and other shop chemicals, making it durable in industrial environments.
  • Superior thermal insulation – Helps protect temperature-sensitive tools stored in unheated spaces.
  • Cost-effective – Often a more economical choice for large boards or high-volume tool storage systems.

EVA vs. PE Foam: Comparison for Laser-Cut Shadow Boards

Please note that the table below has been compiled based on claims by different manufacturers and may be optimistic about properties.

Property EVA Foam PE Foam Better Option for Shadow Boards
Durability & resilience Excellent – tear-resistant, high shape recovery Good – strong but may crack under heavy stress EVA for long-term, repeated use, but may not make a difference in shadow boards
Softness & cushioning Excellent – soft, rubbery texture, protects delicate finishes Moderate to good – firmer and stiffer PE will hold tools in place better
Shock absorption Excellent – absorbs impact energy Very good – protects and braces stored items No significant difference for shadow boards
Cost Moderate Lower – generally more affordable PE for budget-conscious projects
Weight Lightweight Extremely lightweight PE for large wall-mounted boards
Thermal insulation Good Excellent Not relevant
Appearance & finish Smooth, glossy, often vibrant color More textured, matte surface EVA for clean, high-visibility tool layouts

Overall, it seems that PE is the prevalent material for Shadow boards. However, statement is not quantified. To achieve the shadow effect, many users stack two contrasting layers of foam (for example, black on top of yellow). When the top layer is cut out to match tool shapes, the bright bottom layer becomes visible, highlighting the tool outlines.


Design and Layout

Before cutting, a layout of the tools must be created. Digital layout tools help arrange silhouettes for efficient use of space. For example, ToolKaiser is a software tool that allows users to photograph their tools, trace outlines, and export the resulting vector files for laser cutting.


Laser Cutting Workflow

A general workflow for producing shadow boards with a laser cutter is:

  1. Tool Arrangement & Scanning Place the tools on a flat surface, photograph or scan them from above, and import the image into design software.
  2. Vectorization & Layout Trace the outlines into vector paths (e.g., DXF or SVG format) using software like ToolKaiser or a vector graphics editor. Arrange the outlines on the virtual sheet matching the size of the foam.
  3. Laser Preparation Choose PE foam sheets in two contrasting colors. Place the top layer in the laser cutter. Set cutting parameters appropriate for the foam (low power, high speed, multiple passes if needed).
  4. Cutting & Assembly Cut out the tool silhouettes from the top foam layer. Adhere this cut layer onto the contrasting bottom layer using spray adhesive or double-sided tape.
  5. Finishing Mount the finished foam shadow board into a drawer, tool chest, or onto a wall panel.

Notes

  • This article is based on preliminary research and should be treated as a general overview rather than a complete manufacturing guide.
  • Please make sure the foam is safe to cut. It is usually a good idea to source PE foam from Europe in order to avoid being in the dark about potential additives.

Results

<<<PHOTOS?>>>

Further Reading